The poorly puffin passed away despite being cared for by the GSPCA over the space of two days.
He was rescued more than a week ago and was the first of his kind to be found in Guernsey since 2014.
However, experts say he had ingested too much oil after arriving coated in the substance and it is 'almost impossible' to rehabilitate birds in that condition because they try to clean their feathers.
He died two days after his rescue.
GSPCA manager Steve Byrne says it's an incredibly sad moment.
"We were all incredibly upset when we were unable to save Oscar Puff the puffin.
It is rare for puffins to come into any rescue and when any bird comes in oiled they are often poisoned from cleaning the oil off themselves.
We strive to help over 2000 wild animals and birds every year."

Guernsey dance school upset by temporary theatre closure
Guernsey's business leaders come out against a plan to pause GST
Plans to improve the gene pool of the Royal Golden Guernsey Goat
Fog causes flight chaos at Guernsey Airport
Channel Islanders asked to report injured or dead seabirds
More than 200 emergency callouts for overflowing cesspits in Guernsey
Guernsey Library to host Costume Creation event ahead of World Book Day
Domino's Pizza to open in Guernsey